Tally's Ice Cream Menu

The best ice cream made in Wisconsin!

Ice Cream at Tally’s Dockside

Whether you’ve spent the day ashore or on the water, ice cream always hits the spot. Tally’s Dockside offers boatloads of flavors made with real ingredients. It’s not low-fat, low-calorie, or low in flavor. That’s why everyone loves it!

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream logo

Enjoy a scoop, float, shake, or malt today.

Nutritional Information: Don’t even ask. This is the BEST ICE CREAM made in Wisconsin, and it tastes so good because it has GOBS of rich Wisconsin cream, tons of real ingredients for BOAT-LOADS of LUSCIOUS FLAVORS. That means it’s not low-fat, low-calorie or low-anything, and that’s why EVERYONE LOVES IT. YOU WANT NUTRITION, EAT CARROTS.


Ice Cream Options & Prices

16 Delicious Flavors!
JUNIOR one scoop cake or sugar cone…..2.75
SINGLE two scoops cake cone, sugar cone or dish…..3.70
SINGLE two scoops waffle cone…..4.95
DOUBLE four scoops cake cone, sugar cone or dish…..5.40
DOUBLE four scoops waffle cone…..6.95
floats malts & shakes…..6.00


Ice Cream Flavors

(flavors subject to change)

Birthday Cake
Black Cherry
Blue Moon
Bourbon Pecan Pie
Brownie Cascade
Butter Pecan
Cake Batter Fudge
Coconut Almond Bliss
Cookie Dough
Expresso Oreo
Fat Elvis
Key Lime Pie
Mackinac Island Fudge
Mint Avalanche
Old Fashioned Vanilla
This $&@! Just Got Serious
Ultimate Oreo
Yippee Skippee
Zanzibar Chocolate